Vista and the simian brain
In addition to the Macbook Pro where I do all my daily work I have a Dell workstation that for the last couple of years has been running Window 2003 Server. Over the course of the last few months he’s started flaking out on me, to the point where I was never really sure what I was going to get when I used it.
To be fair, it really isn’t the right hardware for Windows 2003. (For instance the hard drive has always run like a pig because it really isn’t a server machine.) But I kept having this feeling that whenever I would turn my back the screensaver would switch over to a giant middle finger pointing at me.
I could never catch him in the act though. Each time I spun around and yelled “Ah ha! Now I’ve got you!” all I would see would a picture of some forest or a planet or something. I’ve gotta admit, while his performance was barely better than some of those losers on American Idol he was a wily one.
Anyhow, the time had come to start anew so I nuked Windows 2003 and put on, yep you guessed, Windows Vista.
A blog wouldn’t be a blog without moaning and complaining so here, I’ll get this out of my system fast:
1. When an install sits on 27% for about a half hour, that’s not good. Luckily I had some outside confirmation that this kind of thing would happen. I think the exact words were “Yeah, it takes freaking forever to install.”
2. Those little security dialog warning popup do-dad’s are pretty annoying, but not because they happen all the time. What’s crazy is the whole screen going black except for this little dialog. As someone who remembers the old Linux days of “Don’t mess with the refresh rate lest your monitor will burst into flames” having a screen go instantly black is a jarring experience.
3. The thing talks to you like HAL from 2001. No seriously, I came into work and noticed this little icon on the login screen:

My first thought was, “What does that do? Let’s click it without thinking through my actions to find out.” Why is it software tends to turn off the higher level reasoning in your brain? I mean, if someone walked up to me and asked, “Does this look infected?” you can take it to the bank that I’m not going to go in for a closer look. Yet an unknown button that could do anything from making me a bacon sandwich to ending all life as we know it gets clicked with nary a thought.
Turns out if you click it Vista starts talking to you in the name of accessibility. To bad they didn’t spring for James Earl Jones to do the voice over instead of some psycho killer computer voice.
But, all that being said, here’s the thing…
I find that I actually LIKE Windows Vista.
Now, before everyone falls all to pieces on me let me explain. My biggest beef with XP was that whenever I would switch back and forth from the Mac to Windows it felt like I was taking a step backwards. The XP interface wasn’t as nice, things seemed to be kind of dull in comparison to shininess of OS X. With Vista’s Aero Glass interface that feeling that I’m taking a step back to something more primitive kind of goes away. (But not completely, I mean it is still Windows right? Snark. Woo hoo! I’ve still got it baby!)
Now, I’m not saying that I prefer Vista over OS X, let’s not start talking crazy here. But, the new eye candy certainly helps. Of course all this could really mean is that I have brain of a chimpanzee and that I would be enamored by anything reflective.
*Eyes reader suspiciously*
First monkey comment and I swear I’ll fling poop at you. Wait, oh crap. (Ha! Ba dum ching!)

[...] Original post by Grant and a wordpress plugin by Elliott [...]
Pingback by Article Feed » Vista and the simian brain — February 21, 2007 @ 9:45 am
Oh please not another MAC vs PC debate
Vista installed fine for me, it’s been my daily OS for 1 week now. The first thing you have to turn off is the “Cancel or Allow”, if you use Vista everyday and are doing anything serious it will drive you crazy (although I do like the black screen it gives you). Don’t cry, but to be honest Areo has OS X beat, plus have you seen DreamScene yet? Pretty cool
Comment by Tim — February 22, 2007 @ 2:06 pm
Nothing beats the sleek shiny veneer of the MS Windows 3.1 UI.
I wonder how many Vista graphic design people use Mac’s. I bet at least one, he or she might work from home, a long, long, long way from Redmond (like Tibet or something), but at least one.
Comment by Pat — February 27, 2007 @ 11:00 am
If you really want to inhabit a living nightmare, try using Surround SCM and Visual Studio 2005 on Vista.
Comment by DOK — May 16, 2007 @ 2:47 pm
Sounds like your problem with XP could have been saved by a shiny XP theme of some sort. With an installation time of ~ 5-10 mins. Before you drop too far into the Vista well be sure to turn off the indexing, that thing bogs down the machine like an mp3 player on a 486.
Comment by Yan — May 16, 2007 @ 3:12 pm
The big problem I’ve had with Surround on Vista is it kicking the UI into the Basic Mode instead of the Aero Glass shininess. That is definitely written up as a bug that is being investigated.
Admittedly I do not use the Surround VS 2005 integration because I’ve never gotten into using IDE SCM integrations. (Old school and whatnot.)
Comment by Grant — May 16, 2007 @ 3:28 pm